Just a quick note based on the Second Circuit’s recent ruling in Andy Warhol Found. for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, where it determined that Warhol’s Prince series was not transformative and therefore was subject to copyright provisions in relation to the reference photograph Warhol used. The court went through a fair use analysis, and the case was primarily concerning copyright, but it is interesting to contrast this decision with the Comedy III case, which was primarily Right of Publicity-related. In Comedy III, the Three Stooges artwork was held to not be sufficiently transformative, and the court used Warhol’s Blue Marilyn as the example of a work that would, in contrast, and in the court’s estimation, be sufficiently transformative. I’ll let those motivated to seek more run their own searches rather than post links here, as there is no lack of content, analysis and discussion being offered on this recent ruling. I have not, as yet, seen reference to the contrast with the Comedy III case, so I thought it may be useful to note it here.
April 30, 2021 No Comments »
Tags: @FaberLaw, advertising, appropriation, artist reference, celebrity licensing, consulting, copyright, defendants, expert valuation, expert witness, Faber, fair use, false endorsement, guide to right of publicity, http://www.LuminaryGroup.com, http://www.rightofpublicity.com, https://www.RightOfPublicity.com, infringement, infringement valuation, J. Faber, Jonathan Faber, licensing, Luminary Group, LuminaryGroup.com, name image likeness, NIL, NIL valuation, professor of right of publicity, publicity rights, publicity rights expert, publicity rights online, publicity rights professor, Right of Publicity, right of publicity analysis, right of publicity author, right of publicity CLE, Right of Publicity expert, right of publicity guide, right of publicity info, right of publicity online guide, right of publicity prof, right of publicity professor, right of publicity resource, right of publicity speaker, right of publicity valuation, right of publicity website, RightofPublicity.com, Second Circuit, teach right of publicity, transformative use, unauthorized use of personality, using celebrities in advertisements, valuation, valuations, value of unauthorized use, Warhol Blue Marilyn, Warhol Prince series, Warhol v. Goldsmith, what is a transformative use, what's it worth